Make smoking cool again to increase wealth turnover

I saw this claim going viral about Warren Buffett’s Cherry Coke habit:

And then there’s Jack Nicholson, now 89, whose last film appearance was in 2010–and who, judging by the photo, hasn’t set foot in a gym since The Shining:

Has anyone else noticed how many elites live a really long time? What is the deal with all these famous people living to 90 or 100, including some who seem to disregard the usual advice about diet and exercise? Buffett is 96 and, despite eating like a six-year-old (his own description), is still going strong. Or take William Shatner, who is 95. Or Henry Kissinger, who lived to 100 despite a diet his son described as heavy on bratwurst and Wiener schnitzel, with an interest in sports confined to watching them.

The list goes on: Charlie Munger lived to 99, David Rockefeller to 101, media mogul Sumner Redstone to 97, and publishing billionaire Walter Annenberg to 94. Having tons of money and status probably helps, if only by reducing financial stress and making the best medical care available. There may be something to that.

But there is a greatly overlooked explanation for the unusual longevity of today’s elites–the end of smoking. In the first half of the twentieth century, smoking was close to universal among celebrities and business elites. It was a social occasion and a way to fill time. Smoking falling out of fashion was probably the single greatest boost to life expectancy–more so than modern medicine or other technology. True, antibiotics played a major role, but they don’t work in COPD, heart failure, or lung cancer. Indeed, smoking rates have plunged since the 1960s, when more than half of adult men in the U.S. smoked:

Source: National Cancer Institute.

It goes without saying that smoking is associated with an increase in all-cause mortality. Smoking, specifically cigarettes, sets a hard cap on life expectancy. Smokers tend to die ten years sooner than people who never smoked. Thus, elites who never took up the habit or quit early have a better chance of living out their lives without the premature kicking of the bucket that tended to befall lifelong smokers. Famous examples include Walt Disney (65), Nat King Cole (45), Edward R. Murrow (57), and Yul Brynner (65), all longtime smokers who died before 70 from lung cancer or its complications.

Fast-forward to today, and things have reversed: the people who still don’t heed the health warnings–including the ones on the packages–are disproportionately the poor, not the elite.

Economists such as Tyler Cowen have bemoaned how America has become too complacent and risk-averse, leading to stagnation. Maybe a revival of smoking is one way to shake America out of its stupor–or, in this case, blow smoke in its face until it wakes up. Here’s my modest proposal: make smoking cool again. If it were, wealthy elites might die sooner, freeing up positions and capital and authority and making America more dynamic, the way it seemed to be in the middle of the twentieth century–the era of the Manhattan Project, the transistor, the interstate highway system, and the moon landing.

There is a real idea underneath this. Max Planck is often paraphrased as saying that science advances one funeral at a time, and this has some empirical support: Azoulay and colleagues found that after star life scientists die, their fields see a surge of contributions from outsiders pursuing different ideas. The rise of gerontocracy is also a possible cause of stagnation, a theme the blogger Richard Hanania has explored at length in essays such as “Gerontocracy Versus Western Civilization” and “Critical Age Theory.” Elites may stay in power well after their mental acuity peaks, possibly holding the country back. Congress, corporate boards, and the ranks of the wealthy all skew old, and incumbents who hold power and capital too long slow turnover and keep bad or obsolete ideas alive well past their expiration date.

Steve Jobs co-founded Apple at 21. Bill Gates co-founded Microsoft at 19, Mark Zuckerberg launched Facebook at 19, Michael Dell founded Dell at 19, and Larry Page co-founded Google at 25. There is a narrow window, before family obligations set in, for turning an idea into a business or pursuing a new line of research. Meanwhile, those in positions off power settle into protecting what they already built, avoiding risk and, in effect, pulling up the ladder behind them. Complacency and stasis set in. Freeing up that capital and those positions gives the next generation a chance, whether in business, Hollywood, or academia. Indeed, some may be surprised to learn that as recently as 1994, universities, including the University of California, could force professors to retire at 70, until an amendment to the federal age discrimination law took that power away.

The idea is also not entirely new. Pareto described a circulation of elites, and a 2000 report commissioned by Philip Morris’s Czech subsidiary argued that smoking saved the government money, in part because smokers’ early deaths reduced pension and healthcare costs. After the report gained media attention in 2001, the backlash was enough to force the company to recant. Just broaching the idea that smoking might have had unintended benefits for society is enough to induce a paroxysm of outrage, not unlike a COPD-induced coughing fit.

A wealthy person who lives to 90 passes wealth to heirs late, while one who dies at 70 passes it sooner. Repeated over many generations, dying 10-20 years sooner has a significant compounded effect. Inheritances also arrive late, often when heirs are already in their 50s or 60s, past their prime, when the ambition and energy of youth have faded. Wealth taxes are fraught: there are constitutional questions in the US, valuing illiquid assets is hard, and most European countries that tried them have repealed them. Still, dying sooner is one of many ways to speed turnover, and one that is voluntary through choice, not trying to force legislation. If the elites won’t pass the torch, maybe they’ll at least use it to light a cigarette.