In 2008 & 2009 as the market was falling, deep pocketed businesses and organizations were frantically looking for explanations as to what happened. Behavior psychologists and 'contrarian' thinkers like Taleb, Gladwell, Ariely, DeLevitt & Dubner of Freakonomics fame, etc rapidly rose to preeminence on the lecture & book circuit, because the 'traditional' models had, apparently, in the span of two years, completely failed. Everyone wanted answers, and these pop psychologists would provide it. We are irrational! We can't manage or see risks! Fast forward four years, and we're back to stocks always going up, housing speculation, record consumer spending, record profits & earnings, and record bonuses.
Smartism -the emphasis on IQ, which was dismissed in Gladwell's Outliers book, is more important than ever as low paying, low IQ jobs are rapidly being supplanted by smarty jobs, or eliminated at together. The meritocracy and American hegemony has been emboldened, as more people than ever become multi-millionaires and billionaires through stocks, real estate, speculation, and web 2.0 while the US has the best performing stock market, currency, and lowest yields of any developed country. If 2008 was supposed to be a paradigm shift, it was more of a blip and the forever irrational, risk oblivious status quo has resumed control.
The takeaway is that Tyler and these other folks are right, and the right (but especially the left) need to acknowledge economic reality instead of believing that this will only be temporary. Average is over. Unless you bring extraordinary abilities to the table, you likely will be left behind and policy makers won't care - not because they are indifferent, but because that would be like interfering with evolution.